AgileEngine vs ImpactQA

Short answer

AgileEngine scores 21.4 and ranks 9; ImpactQA scores 22.1 and ranks 8 of 12. They differ most on test-type depth: AgileEngine 6.0, ImpactQA 2.0 out of 10. ImpactQA: One test type evidenced on security products: automation.

Eight dimensions side by side

Scores out of 10 from the frozen methodology. The difference column is A minus B.

Dimension	A: AgileEngine	B: ImpactQA	Difference (A minus B)
1. Security-product evidence depth	2.0	4.0	−2.0
2. Product-class coverage	2.0	2.0	±0.0
3. Test-type depth	6.0	2.0	+4.0
4. Engagement longevity	0.0	0.0	±0.0
5. Third-party review signal	0.0	0.0	±0.0
6. Vendor's own security posture	0.0	0.0	±0.0
7. Team scale and specialisation	0.0	3.0	−3.0
8. Transparency	5.0	5.0	±0.0

Security-product evidence side by side

AgileEngine

e-0038
case-studyCase study, SOAR and incident response
agileengine.com · undated · B single source · verified 2026-11-11
SOAR and incident response; tests: functional, automation, api; client not named

ImpactQA

e-0041
case-studyCase study for Exostar, identity and access management
impactqa.com · undated · B single source · verified 2026-11-11
Identity and access management; tests: automation; client: Exostar; vendor-reported metric: Reduce QA Test Cycle by 60%

Choose one or the other

Choose AgileEngine when

You need functional testing and API testing evidenced on a security product (test-type depth, 6.0 against 2.0). AgileEngine: Three test types evidenced on security products: functional, automation, api. [e-0038] ImpactQA: One test type evidenced on security products: automation. [e-0041]

Choose ImpactQA when

You want a QA-only company (team scale and specialisation, 3.0 against 0.0). ImpactQA: Headcount not confirmed by two consistent sources, 0 points; QA-only company, 3 points; no dedicated security-product QA page, 0 points. [e-0043] AgileEngine: Headcount not confirmed by two consistent sources, 0 points; not QA-only, 0 points; no dedicated security-product QA page, 0 points.
More published security-product cases weigh most for you (security-product evidence depth, 4.0 against 2.0). ImpactQA: One verified security-product QA item. Of these, one names the client, zero state team size or duration and one states a metric. [e-0041] AgileEngine: One verified security-product QA item. Of these, zero name the client, zero state team size or duration and zero state a metric. [e-0038]

Next steps

Scores are computed from publicly available evidence as of the verifiedOn date on each item. They describe published evidence, not service quality. Re-verify with the vendor before contracting.